CAD Appraisals Jump 10.8% From Last Year, Sparking Fulshear Tax Protest Group
May 20th, 2009 | by Bob Dunn | Published in News | 4 Comments
Despite the national real estate crunch, a preliminary valuation of all Fort Bend County property by the county Central Appraisal District shows a total of $42.2 billion - up 10.8% from last year.
County officials expect property tax disputes to reduce that amount, leaving a net overall increase in property values of about 9%, according to an email sent by Fort Bend County Auditor Ed Sturdivant.
Fort Bend County Judge Bob Hebert called it “good news” as it applies to providing money to keep county operations going.
But preliminary land appraisals, sent out by the CAD to property owners this month, sent shock waves through Fulshear and Simonton, where residents have formed a new group - Citizens Against High Tax Appraisals.
Interviews with CAD officials earlier this year - and with county commissioners on Wednesday - show that land valuations vary greatly from one portion of the county to another.
In precincts 2 and 4, commissioners Grady Prestage and James Patterson each said they have fielded no complaints at all from citizens about this year’s proposed appraisals.
But in Precinct 3 - which includes most of Fulshear - it’s a different story.
“I’m getting a lot more complaints from commercial property owners,” Commissioner Andy Meyers said. “I mean a lot more than I usually get.”
In Precinct 1, Commissioner Richard Morrison said he’s received complaints, adding, “there’s going to be some folks that are pretty upset.”
Both he and Meyers have received email from Citizens Against High Tax Appraisals, whom Morrison said are “sharpening up their knives and getting their torches ready.”
Prestage said it’s possible his office hasn’t received complaints about high appraisals this year because some areas in his precinct have seen values lowered. Also, he noted that Fort Bend County Commissioners Court does not set property appraisals.
That’s done at the CAD. Meyers noted that, despite complaints about appraisals, Chief Appraiser Glen Whitehead is charged under state law with maintaining property appraisals in the county at 95% of market value, at least.
Nonetheless, Meyers indicated he understands what motivates property owners to complain about their appraisals, adding that his own property increased close to 10% last year and about the same again this time.
“I can’t believe my house went up almost 20% in two years,” he said. “And I don’t know if I could get that on the market.”
But in Fulshear and Simonton - where numerous new housing developments have sprung up - some residents and commercial property owners apparently are struggling with huge increases in appraised value.
“After receiving our tax appraisals for Fulshear/Simonton and surrounding areas, we have been forced to face the possibility of having to seel, foreclose or lose our properties to delinquent taxes at the end of the year,” said area resident Melisa Roberts in a widely circulated email announcing the formation of Citizens Against High Tax Appraisals.
Roberts couldn’t immediately be reached for comment Wednesday morning. However, she said in her email, “In an era of a failing economy, other areas of Fort Bend County saw a decrease in their property values, while our area saw an increase of as much as 2,300%. Please join us in an effort to protest our taxes as a community.”
Hebert had said in early March he anticipated county property values would increase between 8 and 10% this yea.
The county, as with school districts and cities, depends on property tax revenue to fund operations. But while it appears increased appraisals will keep county coffers full this year, Hebert is cautioning county department heads about 2010.
“…The full impact of the real estate market downturn would not be felt until Jan. 1, 2010,” he said in a recent email to county officials. “I urge everyone to hold to our budget targets for this year as best we can so that we can continue to meet our debt service needs, avoid unnecessary layoffs and other service curtailments, and keep our tax rate stable throughout the recession.”
While official Fort Bend appraisals are poised to rise again, albeit at a slower increase than last year, actual overall Fort Bend home sales prices appear to have declined as of January 2009 - the month from which appraisal values are calculated.
Data compiled by the Texas A & M University Real Estate Center shows that the average price for a home sold in Fort Bend County in January 2008 was $205,200. The average sales price for a home sold in the county during January 2009 was $190,900. That represents a drop of $14,300 - or about a 7% decline.
Similarly, the median price of a Fort Bend County home sold in January 2008 was $171,200, while the median price in January 2009 was $160,900 - more than $10,000 less, according to the TAMU figures.


May 21st, 2009 at 5:13 pm (#)
The way counties in Texas appraise residential real estate really is a sham. The appraisal districts rely on lazy people who would rather watch American Idol or the “guess what’s in the suitcase show” instead of taking the time to protest their property taxes and they also rely on misinformed people who are gullible enough to believe that the appraisal district is doing them a favor by jacking up their property value which in return jacks up the amount that they pay in property taxes each year so the government can keep it’s coffers inflated. When I tell most people that their appraised value for tax purposes has nothing to with what they could actually sell their house for they look at me like I’m from Mars. It’s scary and sad how complacent and/or misinformed the general public is on this issue and most other political issues.
What exactly qualifies the “appraisers” who work for the county to appraise my residential property? Appraisers (the ones who do appraisals for banks when the banks client is getting a loan for a house) have to go to school and then maintain a license. Are the appraisers that work for the county licensed appraisers?
Even if they are licensed have can they in good conscience say that they are appraising homes at “market value” when they don’t even go inside the house? True market value involves much more than driving by the front of a house or getting out and measuring the base of the house to see how many square feet it has. To come up with true market value you have to take into consideration the condition of the inside of the house as well as how recently its been updated and the sales prices of comparable homes that have sold in the general vicinity over the last few months. County appraisers do not go inside houses.
Do county appraisal boards even have access to sold date for residential real estate? I was under the impression that sold data was not public information in the State of Texas and that you had to be licensed real estate agent or licensed appraiser to access this data. If you don’t have access to sold data than its impossible for you to know the market value of a piece of residential real estate. Also true square footage is determined by measuring the inside of a room from wall to wall. I can’t understand how the county can get away with saying they are taxing people at market value when they aren’t even doing the type of appraisal that is required to determine market value.
The market value of residential real estate does vary through out the year so if property isn’t being reassessed on at least a quarterly basis then most likely whatever the appraisal district has listed as market value is not accurate.
The article noted that the chief appraiser is charged with keeping property values for tax purposes at 95% of market value. Who is charged with making sure that the property values aren’t over inflated for tax purposes? I do not believe that property values have gone up 8-10% over the last year considering the state of the economy and the fact that credit has dried up and people aren’t able to get loans for houses as easily as they have been able to in the past.
These are all very valid questions and this would an excellent topic for an investigative reporter to investigate. I have heard that the appraisal board is appointed and not elected so while the investigative reporter is at it they could also investigate that. If in fact those positions are appointed and not elected how would the county go about making them elected positions?
May 21st, 2009 at 10:32 pm (#)
Tax code 42.24 Judicial Review;
Where assessment by elected officials, it is shown that taxing authorities have in effect on taxation plan to pay new issues with higher appraisal valuations(legal or illegal). It effects state constitution.
May 23rd, 2009 at 8:05 am (#)
You could hear the Appraisal chief say in public that he doesn’t care what the state written policy says, as printed. Thats misleading for more home foreclosures. Higher illegal appraisal values.
May 24th, 2009 at 6:56 pm (#)
FBCAD is helping US Banks tobe nationalize, with more bailouts costing taxpayer more, from increase of home foreclosures. The Ft. Bend is the Lone Star county in Texas with the highest number of foreclosure lead by our county commissioners.